These Monster Donut Eyeballs are fun, spooky treats perfect for a party! Made from fluffy donuts, colorful icing, and candy eyes, they’re sure to catch everyone’s attention.
Who wouldn’t want to eat a cute eyeball? 😂 I love to serve them at Halloween gatherings, and they’re so easy to make! Just grab some donuts, decorate, and enjoy the giggles!
Key Ingredients & Substitutions
Donuts: I recommend using either glazed or unglazed round donuts. Glazed donuts add a sweet base, while unglazed can let the decorations shine. If you can’t find donut options, you can even use store-bought donut holes!
White Icing: A smooth texture is key to mimic the eyeball’s white part. If you’re in a hurry, a premade frosting can work. You could even use cream cheese frosting for a tangy twist!
Candy Eyeballs: These give the monster donuts their life! If you can’t find them, you could use chocolate-covered candies and add edible food coloring to create the iris and pupil.
Red Decorating Gel: This is crucial for the bloodshot look. If you don’t have it, melt red candy melts or mix powdered sugar with red coloring to make your own. You can also use raspberry sauce for a fruity touch.
Black Decorating Gel: If you want to skip this, that’s okay! The donuts still look creepy without the extra details. You could also use melted chocolate if you prefer that flavor.
What’s the Best Way to Decorate These Donut Eyeballs?
Decorating these Monster Donut Eyeballs is where the fun begins! Here’s a quick breakdown to help you master this stage:
- Handle the donuts carefully to avoid breakage—especially the cream-filled types. Place them on a tray that’s easy to move.
- Spread the white icing evenly. A spatula or butter knife works well. You want it to be thick enough to hold the candy eyeballs.
- When placing the candy eyeballs, press them gently so they stick without squishing the icing too much.
- Use a steady hand when drawing the bloodshot lines. Practice on a piece of parchment paper if you need to. It helps maintain control.
- The red licorice adds a fun texture. You can cut them in various lengths for a creepy effect. Don’t worry about perfection—it adds to the monster charm!
Have fun with it—these donuts are all about creativity and a little bit of mess!
How to Make Monster Donut Eyeballs
Ingredients You’ll Need:
- 12 plain round donuts (glazed or unglazed)
- White icing or white glaze (enough to cover the tops of donuts)
- Assorted candy eyeballs (large size, various colors)
- Red decorating gel or red icing (for bloodshot veins)
- Black decorating gel or black icing (optional, for extra vein details)
- Red licorice strings or red candy ropes (for 3D bloodshot veins)
How Much Time Will You Need?
This fun project takes about 15-20 minutes to prepare and decorate the donuts. Make sure you have everything ready to go so you can enjoy the edible art! Allow the decorated donuts to rest for a few minutes to let the icing set before serving.
Step-by-Step Instructions:
1. Set Up Your Space:
Begin by placing the plain donuts on a flat surface or serving tray. This will make decorating easier and keep everything organized!
2. Ice the Donuts:
Spread a generous layer of white icing or glaze over the top surface of each donut. This will represent the eyeball’s sclera (the white part of the eye). Allow it to set slightly but keep it tacky enough for the candy to stick.
3. Add the Candy Eyeballs:
Carefully press a large candy eyeball gently into the center of the white icing on each donut. Make sure it sinks in a bit, but don’t squish the icing too much!
4. Create Bloodshot Veins:
Using the red decorating gel or icing, draw thin squiggly lines radiating out from the candy eyeball on the white icing. This mimics the look of bloodshot veins and adds a spooky flair!
5. Add Dimension with Licorice:
For some extra spooky 3D detail, cut small pieces of red licorice strings and arrange them sticking out from around the candy eyeball. Secure them lightly into the white icing to hold them in place.
6. Optional Black Details:
If you want to add even more detail, use the black decorating gel to add extra vein lines here and there for a true monster effect. Be creative—there’s no wrong way!
7. Let Them Rest:
Once you’ve decorated all your donuts, let them rest for a few minutes. This will help the icing and decorations set so they don’t smudge when you serve them.
8. Serve and Enjoy!
These spooky Monster Donut Eyeballs will delight and spook your guests at any gathering! They’re perfect for Halloween parties or fun themed events. Enjoy the ooohs and aaahs as everyone takes a bite!
Happy decorating!
Can I Use Store-Bought Donuts for This Recipe?
Absolutely! Store-bought donuts save time and can be just as delicious. Choose plain round donuts for the best effect, whether glazed or unglazed. Donuts from your local bakery can also add a fresh touch!
How Do I Store Leftover Monster Donut Eyeballs?
Store any leftover donuts in an airtight container at room temperature. They’re best enjoyed within 1-2 days for optimal freshness. Avoid refrigerating them, as that can make the donuts dry out quicker.
Can I Use Different Types of Candy for the Eyeballs?
Definitely! If you can’t find candy eyeballs, consider using chocolate-covered candies or marshmallows. You can also use your favorite candy that can be decorated for the iris and pupil. Get creative!
Is There a Vegan or Gluten-Free Option for These Donuts?
Yes! You can find vegan or gluten-free donuts at many grocery stores or bakeries. Just replace the ingredients in the recipe with suitable alternatives, such as dairy-free icing. The decorating process remains the same!
